Chattel Loans vs Mortgages

Financing

The loan, not the house, is what makes this expensive

A chattel loan is secured solely by the manufactured home and not the land. A manufactured home mortgage is secured by the home and the land together². Whether you own the ground underneath decides which one you get, and that in turn drives cost and security of tenure².

The gap is large and it is federally documented. In a June 2026 proposed rule, FHFA reported that borrowers seeking personal property, or chattel, loans face a 65.6 percent denial rate against 8.8 percent for site-built homes, and that approved borrowers pay rates averaging 9.24 percent for personal property loans versus 6.63 percent for traditional mortgages¹. Both figures come from FHFA analysis of 2024 Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data¹. FHFA calls the result a financing gap that frequently offsets the lower purchase price of the home itself¹.

This is the common case, not the edge case. Of 70,700 new manufactured homes placed for residential use in 2025, 50,900 were titled as personal property and only 15,600 as real estate³. FHFA's read of the same survey is that 78 percent of new homes built in 2024 were titled as personal property and 18 percent as real estate¹, and the Census series has held near that split for at least five years⁴.

Six differences between the two loan types

The published comparisons come from two federal reports, one using 2019 data and one using 2024 data. Both point the same direction.

What secures the loan

Chattel loans are secured solely by the manufactured home and not land, while manufactured home mortgage loans are secured by the home and land². Whether the homeowner owns the land plays a key role in whether the home is titled as personal or real property².

The interest rate

FHFA's analysis of 2024 HMDA data puts average rates at 9.24 percent for personal property loans against 6.63 percent for traditional mortgages¹. CFPB's earlier look at 2019 HMDA found median rates of 8.6 percent on chattel, 4.9 percent on manufactured home mortgages and 4.1 percent on site-built loans².

The odds of approval

FHFA reports a 65.6 percent denial rate for personal property borrowers against 8.8 percent for site-built¹. CFPB found only 27 percent of manufactured home loan applications resulted in the loan being financed, against 74 percent of site-built applications, and that the difference persisted after controlling for credit score².

The term

For home purchase, CFPB's tables give a manufactured housing chattel loan term of 20 years, against 30 years for both a manufactured home mortgage and a site-built loan². Ten fewer years of amortization at a higher rate pushes the monthly payment two ways at once.

Refinancing, or the lack of it

Chattel originations were 95.9 percent home purchases and only 2.5 percent refinances, a far more lopsided mix than mortgage or site-built lending². CFPB's summary is blunt: compared with mortgages, chattel loans carry higher rates, shorter terms, lower amounts, fewer consumer protections, and are rarely refinanced².

Who is lending

The market is concentrated. The top five lenders made more than 40 percent of manufactured housing purchase loans, including nearly 75 percent of chattel loans and 18 percent of manufactured home mortgages². The four largest originators are specialty lenders serving manufactured housing buyers and offering primarily chattel².

Average rate, personal property loan9.24 percent

Average rate, traditional mortgage6.63 percent

What does it cost?

The most current federal comparison is FHFA's, published June 24, 2026 in its Enterprise Duty to Serve Underserved Markets proposed rule: rates averaging 9.24 percent for personal property loans versus 6.63 percent for traditional mortgages, both from FHFA analysis of 2024 HMDA data¹. CFPB's 2019 figures add the pricing detail: median rate spreads of 5.2 on chattel, 1.6 on manufactured home mortgages and 0.4 on site-built, with 93.8 percent of chattel originations classified as higher-priced mortgage loans against 11.1 percent of site-built².

There is no current rate index for chattel lending. Nothing comparable to a weekly mortgage rate survey exists for personal property manufactured home loans, so the 2024 HMDA average above is the freshest published number, not a live quote. To know today's rate you have to collect quotes. Note what the rate applies to: Census puts the 2025 average sales price of a new manufactured home at $127,200, excluding land, site work and installation⁶.

Rate and denial figures are FHFA's analysis of 2024 HMDA data, published June 2026. Term, spread and refinance figures are CFPB's analysis of 2019 HMDA data. The price is Census 2025 data for the home only.

Hiring

How to shop for manufactured home financing

1

Who does the work

Mostly specialty lenders. CFPB found the four largest manufactured housing originators are specialty lenders that cater to these buyers and offer primarily chattel loans, and that the top five wrote nearly 75 percent of chattel loans². The secondary market is thin: FHFA notes Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have not purchased any chattel loans under their Duty to Serve programs¹.

2

What pros will ask

The first question is whether you own the land, because that decides your eligibility. CFPB found 72 percent of chattel borrowers do not own the land and are ineligible for a mortgage². Expect questions on whether the home will be titled as personal property or real estate, and whether it is single-section or multi-section, which changes FHA Title I limits⁵.

3

What to check before signing

Check whether you could have had a mortgage instead. Over 60 percent of manufactured housing borrowers directly own their land, meaning they may be eligible for a mortgage, yet 17 percent of them take a chattel loan anyway². Then check the term, since chattel purchase terms run 20 years against 30 for mortgages², and assume you will not refinance².

Manufactured home financing questions, answered straight

What exactly is a chattel loan?

It is a loan for manufactured housing secured solely by the manufactured home and not by land². A manufactured home mortgage, by contrast, is secured by the home and the land together². The distinction tracks the title. Whether the homeowner owns the land plays a key role in whether the home is titled as personal or real property, and that affects many aspects of financing, with major implications for cost and security of tenure². Roughly 42 percent of manufactured home purchase loans in HMDA are chattel².

Why is the rate so much higher on a chattel loan?

Federal regulators point at the structure of the market, not the borrower. FHFA describes the chattel lending market as underdeveloped, with limited liquidity, the absence of a securitization infrastructure, and a lack of robust performance data¹. It also notes that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have not purchased any chattel loans under Duty to Serve, despite FHFA designating chattel lending an extra-credit opportunity every year since the program began¹. Thin secondary market demand leaves pricing to a small group of specialty lenders².

Can I get a regular mortgage on a manufactured home?

Yes, if the home and the land are financed together. Manufactured home mortgage loans are secured by the home and land, and CFPB's 2019 data put their median rate at 4.9 percent against 8.6 percent for chattel that year². Land ownership is the gate. CFPB found that 72 percent of chattel borrowers do not own the land and are therefore ineligible for a mortgage², while over 60 percent of manufactured housing borrowers overall do directly own their land².

What is the current chattel loan rate?

No source publishes one. There is no weekly or monthly chattel rate index anywhere comparable to the published mortgage rate surveys, so any single current number you see is a quote, not a survey. The most recent federal figure is FHFA's average of 9.24 percent for personal property loans, drawn from 2024 HMDA data and published in June 2026¹. Treat that as a benchmark for what borrowers actually paid in 2024, and gather your own quotes for today.

How much will FHA insure on a manufactured home loan?

FHA updated its Title I manufactured home loan limits for case numbers assigned on or after March 29, 2024⁵. The manufactured home loan limits are $105,532 single-section and $193,719 multi-section, and the combined manufactured home and lot loan limits are $148,909 single-section and $237,096 multi-section⁵. HUD states the limits are reviewed annually and adjusted if needed, and that it will not lower them from the previous year⁵. Confirm the current figures before relying on them.

Sources

Where these facts came from

Every figure on this page was read out of the page linked below. We do not cite cost aggregators.

Get quotes for your chattel loans vs mortgages project

Free for homeowners. No obligation. Up to four local pros compete.

Get matched now

Keep planning

More guides from the Mobile & Modular Homes hub.